It doesn’t look like she’s as into it as he is. Her arms are just hanging there. My arms would be all over him while trying not to throw him to the ground
I am so happy for Shia, I agree with #12, I didn’t like seeing him walking around alone, sad and pissed off at the paps all the time. He deserves to be happy and I’m personally glad it’s with a real, down to earth, sweet girl rather than someone who is a fake, stuck up, bitch.
I think Shia looks great no matter what but I really, really liked the fine clothes he wore on the WS2 he looked so gorgeous!!
He’s Back with his sexy clothes!!!!! I’m so glad. Well, he’s with her, no comment!!! I’m just jealous… the truth,they are so cute. But she look so BAD !!!!!!!
damn! whats shia’s mom got to do with it?! i agree that careys outfit is not flattering & makes her look pregnant. but she looks nothing like shayna (who is cute & healthy for her age). no need to diss the man’s mama
As much as I am happy for Shia. This seems to be happening way too fast and Shia said he tried to avoid relationships while filming….Blah, you’re better off not saying anything sometimes, Shia.
After Shia had filmed the movie Wallstreet 2 that he wasn’t going to get serious with Carey, so he really meant it this time!! Sometimes i do think that he should be single, and other times that they do make a good couple. Now it breaks my heart!!! But I’m glad Shia got what he really wanted somebody whom he can love like Carey as long as she’s nice!!!
I agreee with you see (#33) by saying that dating comment while filming. Whatever it is what it is and they seem so in love, I am really happy for him, guys you have to remember that Shia is a very sensitive fellow so he falls hard for his co-stars, so will there be an engagement soon?
Is she pregnant? awww little Shi’a running around, that would be adorable.
BTW you all need to check out a post on here if you haven’t already from a Brenda chick who knows shia and said that he and Carey are so happy together. awwww
Well anyone can say they know Shia, and if you are a friend why would you be on here? Brenda says she will not say anything yet she already has…duh.
I think we all wish him the best, and hope that he and Carey are doing great!
I think that this “brenda” is someone who wants Shia to be with Carey. I agree with #38 it is what it is.
IMO I think that Shia looks very happy with Carey so what if her ass is big or not or if she looks like his plump ma blah blah blah, the point is Shia is in love and how long has it been since he has found true love.
Oh and to poster #32 no shit that he is fucking Carey, again he is in “love haven” also he is not a virgin so I am sure that he is getting it on, a lot..
And as for marriage, I dunno about that, but who’s to say, maybe next week we will hear how Shia is getting married to her in the summer of 2010.
With Shia, he is so full of suprises…
i wish them the best. but can we chill on the marriage/pregnant stuff? they’ve only been dating for a few months! and im all for dressing down, but what in the MC HAMMER HELL is goin on with those pants?! lmao NOOOO carey! Epic FAIL! *sings* stop, hammer time, uh o, uh o, uh o, uh o
Hi #43 you really never know they could get married soon. Maybe Shia does not want to suffer another broken heart so he will marry her quickly. I have to agree with “icy” that Shia is full of suprises! Remember how he said he made a trail of roses for his first girlfriend? So who knows, he may have a “romantic” proposal in the works…………………………….
uh, a lot of ppl dont exactly rush into marriage after a bad break up. 3 years with the ex gf & it still didnt pan out. never heard about the trail of roses. but why hurry?! he’s ONLY 23! and on top of that, hollywood marriages dont last too long anyway
and on top of that, hollywood marriages dont last too long anyway
==================================================
You are right about that #45, plus I think 23 is really young for a serious relationship anyway. But some do fall hard and marry that young and sadly divorce not shortly after, not all but most! I am sure that he is completly over his ex and that is why he is so serious with Carey.
I DREAM OR WHAT?
How you can say he will marry with her soon or next summer, you know him,you’re in his private life and head.
I dream, he has only 23 year old, he’s young and have lots professional actor jobs and her too. I don’t think Carey will marry now and in next months either. Yeah, he’s in love, We’re glad for him, well I am. But think he will don’t go to marry with her,It’s totally crazy !!! We will see if he is still with her in next months of 2010…
If he did that, he will surprise me !!!!
ShiaCrazyFan,
I agree with you but with Shia Labeouf he is so full of suprises and I was suprised that he even dated this woman, why, cause he has said countl;ess times that he does not date anyone of his co-stars.
As for him being serious with Carey, has anyone thought that maybe he is on the rebound if he is still not over his ex? Maybe he is trying to put a thorn on ex’s side. God, I hope not cause I would feel really sorry for Carey if that is the case.
I have to agree that he looks so happy, the happiest that i have ever seen him, awww the love what a perfect love story!!!!!
As for him being serious with Carey, has anyone thought that maybe he is on the rebound if he is still not over his ex? Maybe he is trying to put a thorn on ex’s side
================================
Jesus Christ, how much time does a guy need to get over his ex. Didnt he broke up with China almost 4 years ago? Thats a hell of time. I know he was single when he shoot Disturbia and that was in 2006.
some ppl are thinking way too hard about this situation. he’s young and dating. im sure he messed with quite a few chicks on the low before he met carey, maybe there will some after her. its human nature, no big deal
^^WOW. thats a bold move. i would wait to see how WS2 does first. dicaprio whipped out the heavy acting chops and just…wow. anyone else have thoughts on this? good luck to him either way though:)
I really don’t get why Shia dumped his agent. Is it cause Carey told him to? Bad move, people are going to see him as greedy cause he is saving 10%. Doesn’t this guy already have enough money. It seems as if this guy has made it big, starred in a movie like “wall street”, got a serious girlfriend, making blockbusters and now trading stock that he is now big shit in hollywood and he is dumping all over his people helped him make a buck. Blah, that shows what kind of character this “actor” is. I am very disapointed, so sad how he has changed.
It’s laughable that you want to disparage Shia over leaving a fucking agencyt! AN AGENCY!! Who will weep for those poor, poor celebrity agencies? Clearly wet-behind-the-ears Carey must have told him to do it, too.. *rolls eyes* The way you talk Shia just took a piss on some homeless kid’s face. You’re a real fucking idiot, you know that, Bizy? It’s either that, or you work for WME. Piss off, asshole !
Who got him Disturburia? Spielberg…
Who got him Transformer? Spielberg…
Who got him Eagle Eye? Spielberg…
Who got him Indiana Jones? Spielberg…
Stone came to Shia for Wall Street…
Hillcoat came to Shia for The Wettest County…
Shia would eat glass and stick needles in his eyes for Spielberg. He’s no fool.
And according that article, Shia retained his veteran manager and lawyer. Could it possibly be that Shia knows who the real people behind his career are and not some douche troll like you, Bizy? Nah, couldn’t be…
“And according that article, Shia retained his veteran manager and lawyer”
That’s why I love him so much and I like his manager. sometimes he looks like Shia’s dad
I have a question for #58 why didn’t Shia just “can” that agency long ago before he made oodles of bucks and huge films? Why did he have that agency for so many years? Why now? That makes no sense what so ever!!!!! If he thought that they were so horrible he should have gotten rid of that agency long ago, that would have saved him some cash, just a thought.
#56 Carey could be the one that has changed Shia for the worse.
#62 yeah that is what I was thinking arrogance on Shia’s part. Shia should remember where he came from, dirt poor. :/ Why is it that some who go from “rags to riches” and “ugly duckling to a swan” become this arrogant?
arrogance on Shia’s part. Shia should remember where he came from, dirt poor. :/ Why is it that some who go from “rags to riches” and “ugly duckling to a swan” become this arrogant?
========================================================
This is exactly what has come to my mind!
I hope Shia Does Not read some of the crap that is on here. I would think he would dislike many of us for sure.
So Carey wears baggy pants. He likes her and that is what matters.
Who knows if him leaving WME will hurt him or not. As his fans we should hope not.
Best of Luck Shia in all you do!
yeah 68 and i must admit i wear the most dreadful granny clothes with my bf because i just cant be arsed lol!
from experience, jewish boys only want clothes so they can take em off
haha
Okay first to #68 Sorry babe I doubt that Shia has time anymore to read these comments on here because he is spending all of his time with Carey these days, awwww.
As for this this “dumping WME” shit
1. It could be that his finger gives him too much trouble (the one that he crushed) and he can’t do as many films as he could in the past
2. He may want to explore the option of TV movies, Theater or TV shows.
3. He could be ready to settle down and get married and have a family with Carey, yeah I know he is 23 years old but it could happen.
4. He could be going to a university with Carey.
Love changes many things.
Not everything is so bad. Yeah we will all miss seeing Shia if he does deside to cut back drastically from acting. :^(
Hello there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it’s really informative. I am going to watch out for brussels. I’ll appreciate if you continue this in future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!
Nice post. I was checking continuously this blog and I am impressed! Very helpful info specifically the last part I care for such info a lot. I was seeking this particular info for a very long time. Thank you and good luck.
plaid? stop
Betsy | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
oh WOW i still wish it was me but what can i say he looks happy so i will try not to hate 2 much <===but its fucking hard damn it lol
shialuver | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
It doesn’t look like she’s as into it as he is. Her arms are just hanging there. My arms would be all over him while trying not to throw him to the ground
amanda | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
BTW its very good 2 see the grey skinnies & plaid shirt are back not 2 mention the return of the FACIAL HAIR yay!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
shialuver | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
where is this? and what’s with the pants carey?
zelai | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
shawty
biebz | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
This is going to be sooooooooo much fun!!!!!!lol
reggie | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
Why are all Carey clothes so fug?
NATY | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
Lol. nice pants.
maxx | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
She’s such a sweet gal! I’m super happy for him
Or at least that’s what I’m trying to convince myself..haha!
No, really….I love this photograph! He looks super happy and of course SHE’S happy while we’re all “suffering inside”……..
Oh well, live with it!?
For now….
laylaalvar | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
Plus, he’s not walking alone! Which is a good thing fellow Shiantologists, I don’t like seeing him moping around LA alone…….
laylaalvar | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
jealous +_+
sunnie | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
aw adorable. carey’s pants could be better. other than that they are cute as buttons!
shizzyshiz | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
I am so happy for Shia, I agree with #12, I didn’t like seeing him walking around alone, sad and pissed off at the paps all the time. He deserves to be happy and I’m personally glad it’s with a real, down to earth, sweet girl rather than someone who is a fake, stuck up, bitch.
I think Shia looks great no matter what but I really, really liked the fine clothes he wore on the WS2 he looked so gorgeous!!
holl4 | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
Carey looks like a fat girl or pregnant girl! And this pic is breaking my heart…
I love Shia and feel very sad…
naboo | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
Im not sure if its my screen or her clothes that are making her look so huge.
kiki | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
OUCH!!!!
but its okay, its just carey, she’s not the world… as long as shia is happy… but hey girls, this shall pass, ok?…what a sweet sorrow…
ABIGOO | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
oh, we shall call this day as the NATIONAL DAY OF MOURNING..
Sigh….
ABIGOO | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
ahh bless i am happy for them both hope he stays with her forever, she looks like a down to earth gal, not a glamour model thank god!!!
debbie | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
l laughing at shia’s skinny jeans!
Laughing | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
those pants are awful. HORRIBLE, come on Carey, dont dress like you are in your 40s… But they do look happy. Cute
Annie | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
I’m so jealous
nelli | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
He’s Back with his sexy clothes!!!!! I’m so glad. Well, he’s with her, no comment!!! I’m just jealous… the truth,they are so cute. But she look so BAD !!!!!!!
ShiaCrazyFan | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
Carey looks like his mom,
jealous!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Anon | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
SOOOOOOOOOOOO SWEET!!!!!!!!!!
Ashley | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
he totally wore that top on that vote video
i’m sucha stalker x
Lolaframologia | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
Carey is as fat as his mom, but he is happy now.
Agro. | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
damn! whats shia’s mom got to do with it?! i agree that careys outfit is not flattering & makes her look pregnant. but she looks nothing like shayna (who is cute & healthy for her age). no need to diss the man’s mama
geez | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
ahhhhhhh gross
i should be the one just saying haha
love him hes soo adorable
bella | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
i wanna cry. she’s the luckiset girl alive, in my world. literally
Annariam | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
they’re totally fucking
Marissa | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
As much as I am happy for Shia. This seems to be happening way too fast and Shia said he tried to avoid relationships while filming….Blah, you’re better off not saying anything sometimes, Shia.
see | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
maybe i shouldn’t have alerted shiantology about the picture. my apologizes to the broken-hearted…
btw…the picture is taken by his home in LA.
Lila Y | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
ARGH.
jess | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
maybe i shouldn’t have alerted shiantology about the picture. my apologizes to the broken-hearted…
btw…the picture is taken by his home in LA.
=========================
how do you know that LILA? do you have the link? i loved the pic, thank you for posting.
Annie | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
After Shia had filmed the movie Wallstreet 2 that he wasn’t going to get serious with Carey, so he really meant it this time!! Sometimes i do think that he should be single, and other times that they do make a good couple. Now it breaks my heart!!! But I’m glad Shia got what he really wanted somebody whom he can love like Carey as long as she’s nice!!!
Jennifer Nychole | Dec 12, 2009 | Reply
I agreee with you see (#33) by saying that dating comment while filming. Whatever it is what it is and they seem so in love, I am really happy for him, guys you have to remember that Shia is a very sensitive fellow so he falls hard for his co-stars, so will there be an engagement soon?
Is she pregnant? awww little Shi’a running around, that would be adorable.
BTW you all need to check out a post on here if you haven’t already from a Brenda chick who knows shia and said that he and Carey are so happy together. awwww
Song | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
This brenda chick can be found on this part of Shiantology:
http://shiantology.com/2009/12/09/shia-labeouf-missing-person/#comments
Song | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
Well anyone can say they know Shia, and if you are a friend why would you be on here? Brenda says she will not say anything yet she already has…duh.
I think we all wish him the best, and hope that he and Carey are doing great!
jdk03 | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
I think that this “brenda” is someone who wants Shia to be with Carey. I agree with #38 it is what it is.
IMO I think that Shia looks very happy with Carey so what if her ass is big or not or if she looks like his plump ma blah blah blah, the point is Shia is in love and how long has it been since he has found true love.
Oh and to poster #32 no shit that he is fucking Carey, again he is in “love haven” also he is not a virgin so I am sure that he is getting it on, a lot..
And as for marriage, I dunno about that, but who’s to say, maybe next week we will hear how Shia is getting married to her in the summer of 2010.
With Shia, he is so full of suprises…
Icy | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
i wanna cry. she’s the luckiset girl alive, in my world. literally [2]
NATY | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
i wish them the best. but can we chill on the marriage/pregnant stuff? they’ve only been dating for a few months! and im all for dressing down, but what in the MC HAMMER HELL is goin on with those pants?! lmao NOOOO carey! Epic FAIL! *sings* stop, hammer time, uh o, uh o, uh o, uh o
lala | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
Hi #43 you really never know they could get married soon. Maybe Shia does not want to suffer another broken heart so he will marry her quickly. I have to agree with “icy” that Shia is full of suprises! Remember how he said he made a trail of roses for his first girlfriend? So who knows, he may have a “romantic” proposal in the works…………………………….
JM | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
uh, a lot of ppl dont exactly rush into marriage after a bad break up. 3 years with the ex gf & it still didnt pan out. never heard about the trail of roses. but why hurry?! he’s ONLY 23! and on top of that, hollywood marriages dont last too long anyway
lala | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
and on top of that, hollywood marriages dont last too long anyway
==================================================
You are right about that #45, plus I think 23 is really young for a serious relationship anyway. But some do fall hard and marry that young and sadly divorce not shortly after, not all but most! I am sure that he is completly over his ex and that is why he is so serious with Carey.
JM | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
I hope they do break up SOON!!
jen | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
@jen
Hope they will break up too !!!!!!
ShiaCrazyFan | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
I DREAM OR WHAT?
How you can say he will marry with her soon or next summer, you know him,you’re in his private life and head.
I dream, he has only 23 year old, he’s young and have lots professional actor jobs and her too. I don’t think Carey will marry now and in next months either. Yeah, he’s in love, We’re glad for him, well I am. But think he will don’t go to marry with her,It’s totally crazy !!! We will see if he is still with her in next months of 2010…
If he did that, he will surprise me !!!!
ShiaCrazyFan | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
ShiaCrazyFan,
I agree with you but with Shia Labeouf he is so full of suprises and I was suprised that he even dated this woman, why, cause he has said countl;ess times that he does not date anyone of his co-stars.
As for him being serious with Carey, has anyone thought that maybe he is on the rebound if he is still not over his ex? Maybe he is trying to put a thorn on ex’s side. God, I hope not cause I would feel really sorry for Carey if that is the case.
I have to agree that he looks so happy, the happiest that i have ever seen him, awww the love what a perfect love story!!!!!
San | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
As for him being serious with Carey, has anyone thought that maybe he is on the rebound if he is still not over his ex? Maybe he is trying to put a thorn on ex’s side
================================
Jesus Christ, how much time does a guy need to get over his ex. Didnt he broke up with China almost 4 years ago? Thats a hell of time. I know he was single when he shoot Disturbia and that was in 2006.
Julie | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
some ppl are thinking way too hard about this situation. he’s young and dating. im sure he messed with quite a few chicks on the low before he met carey, maybe there will some after her. its human nature, no big deal
lala | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
Shia LaBeouf Leaves WME..
http://www.deadline.com/hollywood/shocker-shia-le-boeuf-leaves-wme/
jen | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
^^WOW. thats a bold move. i would wait to see how WS2 does first. dicaprio whipped out the heavy acting chops and just…wow. anyone else have thoughts on this? good luck to him either way though:)
lala | Dec 13, 2009 | Reply
^
risk move Shia O.O
NATY | Dec 14, 2009 | Reply
I really don’t get why Shia dumped his agent. Is it cause Carey told him to? Bad move, people are going to see him as greedy cause he is saving 10%. Doesn’t this guy already have enough money. It seems as if this guy has made it big, starred in a movie like “wall street”, got a serious girlfriend, making blockbusters and now trading stock that he is now big shit in hollywood and he is dumping all over his people helped him make a buck. Blah, that shows what kind of character this “actor” is. I am very disapointed, so sad how he has changed.
bizy | Dec 14, 2009 | Reply
Has anyone photoshopped their faces into this picture yet?!
Henrietta | Dec 14, 2009 | Reply
It’s laughable that you want to disparage Shia over leaving a fucking agencyt! AN AGENCY!! Who will weep for those poor, poor celebrity agencies? Clearly wet-behind-the-ears Carey must have told him to do it, too.. *rolls eyes* The way you talk Shia just took a piss on some homeless kid’s face. You’re a real fucking idiot, you know that, Bizy? It’s either that, or you work for WME. Piss off, asshole !
Who got him Disturburia? Spielberg…
Who got him Transformer? Spielberg…
Who got him Eagle Eye? Spielberg…
Who got him Indiana Jones? Spielberg…
Stone came to Shia for Wall Street…
Hillcoat came to Shia for The Wettest County…
Shia would eat glass and stick needles in his eyes for Spielberg. He’s no fool.
And according that article, Shia retained his veteran manager and lawyer. Could it possibly be that Shia knows who the real people behind his career are and not some douche troll like you, Bizy? Nah, couldn’t be…
ProudlyCrucifiedJesus | Dec 14, 2009 | Reply
wise Move
Anon | Dec 14, 2009 | Reply
“And according that article, Shia retained his veteran manager and lawyer”
and I like his manager. sometimes he looks like Shia’s dad
That’s why I love him so much
Anon | Dec 14, 2009 | Reply
I have a question for #58 why didn’t Shia just “can” that agency long ago before he made oodles of bucks and huge films? Why did he have that agency for so many years? Why now? That makes no sense what so ever!!!!! If he thought that they were so horrible he should have gotten rid of that agency long ago, that would have saved him some cash, just a thought.
huh? | Dec 14, 2009 | Reply
This was a very arrogant move on Shia’s behalf (the agent thing that is).
missy | Dec 14, 2009 | Reply
#56 Carey could be the one that has changed Shia for the worse.
#62 yeah that is what I was thinking arrogance on Shia’s part. Shia should remember where he came from, dirt poor. :/ Why is it that some who go from “rags to riches” and “ugly duckling to a swan” become this arrogant?
A_Commenter | Dec 14, 2009 | Reply
#56 Carey could be the one that has changed Shia for the worse.
============================================
WTF??????????? really? people are gonna put the blame on CAREY??????? To say is ridiculous and sad no even gets close.
Shia is a fukcing grown man, HE DECIDES WHAT HE WANTS TO DO.
Julie | Dec 14, 2009 | Reply
Carey does look big in those pants.
maybe she could start a new line of big baggy mc hammer pants! x
Lolaframologia | Dec 14, 2009 | Reply
arrogance on Shia’s part. Shia should remember where he came from, dirt poor. :/ Why is it that some who go from “rags to riches” and “ugly duckling to a swan” become this arrogant?
========================================================
This is exactly what has come to my mind!
d | Dec 14, 2009 | Reply
Shia #16 Starmeter Celebrity for 2009
http://www.imdb.com/features/rto/2010/starmeter
Jen | Dec 14, 2009 | Reply
I hope Shia Does Not read some of the crap that is on here. I would think he would dislike many of us for sure.
So Carey wears baggy pants. He likes her and that is what matters.
Who knows if him leaving WME will hurt him or not. As his fans we should hope not.
Best of Luck Shia in all you do!
jdk03 | Dec 14, 2009 | Reply
yeah 68 and i must admit i wear the most dreadful granny clothes with my bf because i just cant be arsed lol!
from experience, jewish boys only want clothes so they can take em off
haha
But still ARGH
jess | Dec 15, 2009 | Reply
Okay first to #68 Sorry babe I doubt that Shia has time anymore to read these comments on here because he is spending all of his time with Carey these days, awwww.
As for this this “dumping WME” shit
1. It could be that his finger gives him too much trouble (the one that he crushed) and he can’t do as many films as he could in the past
2. He may want to explore the option of TV movies, Theater or TV shows.
3. He could be ready to settle down and get married and have a family with Carey, yeah I know he is 23 years old but it could happen.
4. He could be going to a university with Carey.
Love changes many things.
Not everything is so bad. Yeah we will all miss seeing Shia if he does deside to cut back drastically from acting. :^(
Info! | Dec 15, 2009 | Reply
# 70 I agree with your 1-4. I am sure he does not have time to read our thoughts, and I am glad…lol
jdk03 | Dec 15, 2009 | Reply
I dont think he will disappear any time soon as he is signed up to do the Tranny 3 & also the associate
Frankie | Dec 15, 2009 | Reply
Her clothes are seriously gross. Egads!
She just got nominated for a Golden Globe…. mayb e she’ll wear those there?
wah | Dec 16, 2009 | Reply
Hello there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it’s really informative. I am going to watch out for brussels. I’ll appreciate if you continue this in future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!
Calendar 2012 | Aug 7, 2011 | Reply
Nice post. I was checking continuously this blog and I am impressed! Very helpful info specifically the last part
I care for such info a lot. I was seeking this particular info for a very long time. Thank you and good luck.
Niche Finder Review | Aug 29, 2011 | Reply