The bar fight that never ends…

101911-shia-labeouf-video-5-credit

So TMZ found the guy who “helped” Shia after his fight with the hairy shirtless man and his name is Shea Carter. No, really.

The man who tried to calm down Shia LaBeouf moments after the beatdown in Vancouver last week tells TMZ … the actor threatened to pull a knife on him in the wake of the fight … but he never actually flashed a blade.

TMZ spoke with Shea Carter … the man who restrained Shia after the fight … who tells us he noticed the actor inside the Cinema Public House bar BEFORE the melee. Carter says LaBeouf had been drunkenly swaying into several patrons … including one man who calmly warned Shia, “Hey man, watch out.”

Carter says Shia replied, “Oh yea? Or what? What are you going to do about it?”  That’s when the two decided to take things outside … and the guy beat Shia down to the ground.

Afterward, Carter — a local hip hop artist and  bar regular — tried to stop Shia from getting back inside, but LaBeouf got aggressive, spouting, “Well what if I grabbed my knife on you?”

Carter says he quickly grabbed Shia in an effort to protect himself in case the knife threat was serious.

Carter says the actor eventually walked away … so he went back inside the bar. But moments later, Carter says, Shia appeared outside a window and made a throat-slashing gesture at him … before leaving for the night.

Sounds like Shea is a little dramatic… oh and according to his  Twitter he just dropped an “EP” – convenient timing, no??? Let’s hope this is just some random Vancouver local trying to make a buck and not reality.

56 Comment(s)

  1. Look…blaming or implying blame to either drunk (Shia or the man who hit him in the face) or this guy Shea (who came to Shia’s rescue after the man on crutches did first is irrelevant. “The only thing that matters is that Shia gets help.” Don’t be putting a spin on this crap. I’m not listening.
    When & who is going to announce that Shia will be checked for head injuries, etc & that he will be in counseling with a professional? Don’t be giving us your jive spin? What is the plan? You haven’t even told us if he got an OK from a Doctor about his head injuries.

    EmilyVP | Oct 20, 2011 | Reply

  2. STOP STOP STOP to speculate, speak, vomit these news !!!!

    Sonny | Oct 20, 2011 | Reply

  3. Can someone post the link to Karolyn’s tumbler, the translation? thank you.

    ann | Oct 20, 2011 | Reply

  4. THIS IS CAROLYN PHO AND MANSONS FAULT, THEY GOT SHIA WITH THE DEVIL, HE IS BUDDY BUDDY WITH THE DEVIL, SHIA SHOULD HAVE WALKED AWAY FROM CAROLYN PHO THE DAY HE LAID EYES ON HER. SHIA IS GOING DOWN HILL AND FAST, HE IS LISTENING TO HIS NEW MASTERS THE DEVIL AND PHO!

    DISCUSTED | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  5. Although she wants to portray herself as worldly, that is not how Karolyn comes off to me. I think she may be an enabler, and as a result is over her head. I think she loves him and is blind to who he has become.

    ann | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  6. I said before that I don’t think Karolyn Pho is wrapped too tight. She wants to be a big stylist, but she has inappropriate videos at the end of her business site. She says dumb stuff like her motto was use or be used. That doesn’t endear her to anyone. Rumors were she thought MM was great. That ugly has been who was clearly using Shia’s rep to get a boost in his sales…plus she let herself be used to get to Shia by MM. Not terribly bright. Beautiful girl yes…but no character, stands for nothing & makes statement that LaCeinga st pavement is art. What is she smoking?
    She is definitely in over her head.
    Shia needs levelheaded friends and if he has a gf, she’s gotta be levelheaded too. There are a lot of beautiful girls, with waist length dark hair, dark eyes, good figures & level heads. At least he could find one that doesn’t think you have to be paranoid to be at some heightened state of awareness to create art. MM with the Satanic crap reputation is garbage too. If Kpho wants to be a sucessful stylist, she has to walk a fine line to appeal to as many customers as possible…that omits any far out anything that prevents people from liking her. She does the exact opposite & drags our poor lad into.
    She is just not level headed & that is the worst kind of person for Shia to be around. Carey wasn’t his type of sexiness…but she was level headed. They were in NY together for quite a few months, yet no reports of bar brawls, fights, etc..until the nite she had the big premier & he had to get drunk.
    Let’s hope he finds a Kpho look alike with Carey’s brain. That way she can tell him the famous…”It’s me or Jim Beam”line…and maybe Shia will listen.

    EmilyVP | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  7. Shia is a big boy. He was a drunk before he met her and will be one after she is gone. Until he decides to grow up, nothing will change, no matter who his girl is. He has no one to blame but himself for his foolishness. He is a buffoon, as much as it kills me to say. I enjoy his work immensely, but when the actor becomes too big for his roles, then it is difficult to watch a movie and not think about Shia, instead of getting lost in the art. Not what he wants, but what he has created nonetheless.

    ann | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  8. oh Ann… I love you

    Shiass | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  9. he knows exactly what to do to get better. but the thing is he’s a superficial asshole who’s surrounded by people that are just using him (he knows it, he’s using them too). he thinks he can do whatever the fuck he wants because there are no consequences for someone like him.
    I advice him to read the contracts and understands them BEFORE he signs them. people around him only care about themselves (his lawyer, agent, PR whore etc.) they’ll all go to hell. including SHia. he deserves the worst… I hope he loses everything that means sometihng to him in his life. I hope Brando dies slowly.
    if I saw Shia getting punched on the ground, I wouldn’t help him.. I’d walk away and pray that something worse happened to him. that’s how much I hate him.

    klame | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  10. To the person above me, here we go again. Is it the same chick with this condition:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=byOtxwl8iEI
    Emily VP is right, what Shia needs is heavy duty counseling. He is really slipping deeper and deeper. He will lose his money and shit if he stays with that girl who is draining him so badly. What isn’t mama Labeouf speaking up? What about Lo, where the hell is he? Why isn;t he speaking up. Once a few years ago Lo had on his twitter account that he is close to the Lord, I hope to God that didn’t change cause of Shia. Please pray for Shia, he needs it. It would be great if Emily was close to mama Labeouf that way she could befriend her seeing that she is close in age and she could help Shia.
    Also Shia needs and intervention, for his drinking (possible drug use) and for his dating the WRONG type of girl. WOW that girl is HORRIBLE news for Shia, She is baaaaad!
    I guess we all have to keep our eyes on the news and PRAY that there is no more news of such and pray that Shia breaks up with bad news slut-possessed girl (SHE IS UGLY BTW and Shia can do A LOT better)!

    Sigh | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  11. “To the person above me, here we go again. Is it the same chick with this condition:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=byOtxwl8iEI
    yes, you mean that derya lady, yes i can see it everytime i see that video i think of her (i am not making fun of that mental condition at all, i just think that is what she has like that girl in the video). derya/bav, shia need support not hate! take a cue from emily and the others here!

    tap-tap | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  12. You are all crazier than Shia lol.

    :) | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  13. Shia is not crazy, he is an addict with a big ego. He can be helped. At least that is what the voices in my head tell me. :}

    ann | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  14. !!! So damn why you talk like that about Shia? You do not know him and I do not either and this certainly never happen, but unlike you I do not judges Shia’s acts.
    You claim He is too much drunk, he has a big ego, he needs help. Damn but there are thousands of young 25-year going out in the bar every weekend and drink to throw up on the sidewalk and get fights. Shia is one of them. Go to the UK pub in London and Chelsea, Japan, New York, L.A… and Cities Night bar and you will see lots of guy like Shia. He does what he want, when he want, where he want. If they want to destroy his life is his problem. You do not even speak of his new movies project. You want Shia die or get accident? Anyone discuss about Transformers, his old movies or news he will do. You spat to write shit about him claiming that his mother’s family and friends, girlfriend are good or bad for him. Think before you write nonsense things !!!!

    Sonny | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  15. news of a new film for those who are interrested !!!

    http://coronacomingattractions.com/news/shia-labeouf-become-giant

    The Transformers star is now attched to topline A Giant, a drama/fantasy that has Monster House director Gil Kenan also attached as its director.

    The project would see the 25-year-old play a man who’s 20-feet-tall, which is more than a few feet higher than the tallest man on record. The giant lives as a recluse inside his own home until he begins a friendship with a rebellious woman who is his next door neighbor. The two eventually fall in love, and their relationship is described as a “modern day adult dramatic fairy tale.”

    The Jim Henson Company is involved with the project, which suggests that there may be other fantasy elements at play. Also involved creatively are AngeleFine Productions and Lava Bear Films.

    Sonny | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  16. The truth is that some people have no manners and bad mouth to Shia (out of jealousy) and i really know the feeling Shia has if he doesnt do anything back to those that hurt him, if he doesnt do anything back it will keep eating away at him tahst why he does that stuff sometimes. maybe im wrong i dont know.
    Well we don’t live in the television show and even Shia deserves to be drunk and deserves to live once in a while and i hope he kicked that fat dudes his ass before he was tossed to the ground.
    His friends were a little to late to back him up though.I’m glad he didn’t get run over by a car or something that would have been unforgivable.

    Star | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  17. While the drinking & bar fighting is going on all over the country, it’s still not right. My girlfriend’s son was in a bar drinking. He got challenged by another drunk. The other drunk shot him dead. That’s why this has to stop now.
    She has never gotten over it. She adopted his little daughter & has been raising her now some 6 yrs. I think that’s the only reason that his mother got through all this…plus the company we work for did a lot to help my friend. But she told me she thinks of him everyday. The worst part is that when it went to trial, the guy got off.

    EmilyVP | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  18. You are all crazier than Shia lol.

    :) | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply
    ——————–
    Speak for yourself babe!

    :) X2 | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  19. NOVEMBER 2007: shia gets arrested in walgreens.

    JULY 2008: shia’s car accident.

    I hate to break it to all of you, especially you Emily, but this has nothing to do with Karolyn or Marilyn Manson or anything. Shia is problematic. HE ALWAYS HAS BEEN AND HE ALWAYS WILL BE. He grew up with an addict father in a troubled household and until he decides to either seek therapy or give up the drinking & whatever else he is probably doing he’ll never be any better. No one – not even any of you who call yourselves his “FANS” and are supposed to support him and not throw him under the bus and everyone he loves under the bus just because he’s having a rough time – can tell Shia what to do with his life because he is an adult who makes his own decisions and suffers his own consequences.

    Stop with the satanic talk and the Jesus speak and the damning of his family and friends and the people who work for him. Shia is Shia and he always has been and if you don’t like it so much then go find someone else to obsess over. Maybe someone your own age, Emily? You have 40 years on Shia and you’re not his mother even though you could be. Leave him alone.

    lol | Oct 21, 2011 | Reply

  20. he should quit acting.

    suzilyn | Oct 22, 2011 | Reply

  21. I agree with suzilyn

    whorelyn | Oct 22, 2011 | Reply

  22. a date with me costs only 5 dollars. kissing (without tongue) 10, and sex (no oral) 15. please send an email to karolynwhore@gmail.com for bookings. check out my blog diaries of an escort girl.com. xxx

    escort girl uyen khanh | Oct 22, 2011 | Reply

  23. Emily don’t listen to the basket case’s here, keep on with your prayers em. The will work, I believe in Miracles in God’s time. :)
    Shia does need help and we should pray for him instead of insulting SHIA! Shia is a human being not a piece of litter. Treat him with the same respect that you would treat any other human people and stop dissing em and others!

    word UP | Oct 22, 2011 | Reply

  24. @lol

    There’s no age limit on being a fan.

    jenn | Oct 22, 2011 | Reply

  25. @ lol.

    I have often said Shia was in trouble before he met MM and Karolyn. I am still a fan, and find it sad the turn his life seems to have taken. He has the talent and other tools to overcome his childhood, he needs to put his big boy pants on and get his act together. He can’t let his past determine the course of his future.

    That said, while we agree on that …

    You are a bully. Leave Emily alone. I don’t agree with the satanic and Bible beating that goes on here, but at least Emily never, ever, does it in a condescending or cruel way.

    She is harmless and means well, leave her be.

    ann | Oct 22, 2011 | Reply

  26. MORE DETAILS ABOUT SHIA AND THE BLONDIE
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SpDhS0mapXI

    NEWS | Oct 22, 2011 | Reply

  27. Well we can just disagree about ways & means, but I know we all care about Shia getting sober, peaceful & content. I appreciate some have my viewpoints. For those who disagree, I still enjoy reading your views as well because you want whats best for Shia too. But some of us are just going to keep praying anyway.
    OK..but if you go on WCITW at IMDB & go to the message board…there are some interesting things on it. Especially the comments on the prescreening & how it ends. I get the idea that it isn’t finalized yet, so who knows. But I sure wish we could see the trailer by now.
    Also they said that Mia W (Shia’s gf in the movie) has a small role. Well in the book, she really doesn’t surface for a long time. He sees her & it’s love at first site for him. But he plans to go after her when he gets some money, a car & the right clothes to court her. But their romance is such a sweet one, he makes a fool of himself, he says the wrong things, he is so happy to see her, she visits him when he is sick & when he wakes up…he is so happy to know that she was there visiting him while he was unconscious. Plus he gives up his dream of moving out of the county just to keep her happy. She wants to be near her family. It is really a sweet romance & I hope they don’t rob us from seeing the whole thing.
    Since we haven’t see pics of Shia in the rag mags yesterday or today…maybe RR or family had a talk with him. Let’s hope so. We don’t want to hear about anymore injuries.

    EmilyVP | Oct 22, 2011 | Reply

  28. I have a feeling that Shia is doing some kind of drug(s). Here is why I say this theory. I take my regular prescribed meds and mix them up with Dimenhydrinate meds, when I wake up from the high that these meds gives me (I usually pass out) I have noticable dark circles under my eyes than on days when I don’t mix these drugs. I don’t use much cause it does not take me much to get high. This is me, so I am wondering if shia does the same, uses some kind of drug and/or mix it with the booze. Personally I hate the taste of booze and it makes me feel fat so I don’t drink, I stick to the drugs. I worry about Shia, I personally don’t give a fuck if I die, there is no need for me on this earth but I very much worry about Shia and his health, he has a gift and I hate to see him waste it, he such a young lad too.
    Okay that is it, this is just what I go through and I pray that Shia is NOT going through drug abuse. It is all sad :( Oh yes it is a learned behaviour, my mother hits the booze pretty hard and I had to see that all my life. ANd she would hit the booze when things did not go well in her life, that’s me too, I mix it up (my regular prescript drugs and the Dimenhydrinate sometimes). NO I don’t EVER take more than what is prescribed to me, I just mix it up. NOT GOOD I know.
    Just pray for Shia please, he needs it!

    NoName | Oct 23, 2011 | Reply

  29. thegirlx Tracy
    As much as I’m thrilled Shia LaBeouf is living near me, I cannot wait until he leaves so I can wear my Transformers shirts again. #nerdygirl

    thegirlx Tracy
    @AnOceanPearl but you don’t have Shia LaBeouf living less than a block from you :P

    hb_wizard Heather Briscoe
    Such a good day so far! Got my hair did, saw Shia LaBeouf at the Starbucks, and later gonna hang with my niece

    thegirlx Tracy
    Shia LaBeouf and I just crossed paths. Twice. NO BIG DEAL.

    thegirlx Tracy
    Oh, PS while I was on my twitter vacation I saw Shia LaBeouf TWICE in two days. My lady bits were a tinglin’. #YVR

    slbtweets | Oct 23, 2011 | Reply

  30. @noname..you may be right about Shia. I have thought of that too. Also someone could of slipped something to him. (thinking they were big time for doing that to a celebrity). He is such a target (especially now) that he should have a body guard.
    You are worth as much as Shia. Every person’s life is worth as much as every other person’s life on this planet. We are all needed & have a purpose. Sometimes that purpose is obvious, sometimes is it not apparent. Shia is everywhere right now just because he is an actor in a lot of big movies. He has given us great pleasure bringing these characters to life, so we want to see him a lot more. When we see him, he distracts us from anything that bothers us or he is taking away an empty feeling & giving us pleasure. When I first discovered him, my doctors were looking for cancer & turns out I didn’t have it. But I had to quit working, didn’t do much but watch TV, read books & pray. I got complete distraction, pleasure & laughter watching his movies on TV. He made my time go by faster, with some laughter & good actors with good stories do that for us. That’s why you like him too. We all do on this site.
    But Shia is just like us. We see he is adorable, we know he is well paid, we know he has an active love life with beautiful women, he can buy what ever he wants, it seems that everyone adores him, etc. etc.etc… But it’s not like that for him. Shia has the same problems we do…in different ways. Granted he has no money problems, but that could change. He doesn’t feel worthy of his privileged position otherwise he would enjoy it more. He seems to try to thwart his own best interests by sabatoging everything he has…I think he thinks this all happened to him by mistake. It’s not a mistake. He deserves what he has and he is in that situation because he was made specially for it.
    You are made for your role in life & trust me, you are perfect in it. Just because it’s been a struggle so far doesn’t mean it will always be a struggle. And just because someone appears to have it all, doesn’t really mean that they do.
    The longer you are around, the more interesting it all becomes. It’s all clearer, things have more meaning & each day brings more contentment.
    Hang in there NoName with us. We will all watch Shia together & I am hopeful this will turn out good for him & in turn for others too.
    And I guarantee that eventually you will see your present problems disappear & things will get much brighter for you too. Hang in there.

    EmilyVP | Oct 23, 2011 | Reply

  31. I thnk that Shia is just or at least wants to be a normal human being just like all of us and the cause of all these fights is that there are people out there that say stuff to him to start trouble and get known!!! and also Shia takes that too serious and continues with it and I hinsetly think that Shia should just calm down and not take all that too serious come on he has the money to afford better bars. heck, he has money to put him self at the VIP section of a classy bar instead of going to all those drunky bars. I’m just saying all this is coming from the heart of a caring fan of SHIA… so SHIA if you ever get on here and read this .. I LOVE YOU AND PLEASE JUST LET IT ALL GO!! AND PLEASE THINK ABOUT YOUR REAL FANS THAT LOVE YOU AND CARE ABOUT YOU… I REALLY DON’T WANT YOU TO GO DOWNHILL JUST BECUASE OF THESE TYPE OF NONSENCE!!! YOU’RE STILL YOUNG AND THINK ABOUT ALL THE GOOD MOVIES YOU CAN MAKE FOR US (YOUR FANS) :(

    ess217 | Oct 23, 2011 | Reply

  32. Thank you Emily VP :)

    NoName | Oct 23, 2011 | Reply

  33. No pics, no news. His girl must be in town. Hope he had a great weekend. Wonder how filming is going? Can’t wait for this one.

    ann | Oct 23, 2011 | Reply

  34. I agree with ess217. shia should hang out with his kind of people and stop trying to fit in. it’s a joke that he hangs out at bars where normal people go to,,, go make your private new year’s eve party with rob kardashian and your other rich friends. you’re not one of us and you never will be. that’s why they kicked your stinky ass

    a.a.h. | Oct 23, 2011 | Reply

  35. Karolyn just wrote on her blog that she came back from a music festival in new york that took place between 18-23 october… so maybe she did not stay long in Vancouver …

    Heidi | Oct 24, 2011 | Reply

  36. I don’t think that Karolyn was ever with Shia this time in Vancouver. Maybe this is why Shia is staying OUT of trouble!

    Gillie | Oct 24, 2011 | Reply

  37. karolyn hasn’t been to vancouver at all. sorry to burst all your assumption bubbles. don’t believe everything you read on twitter/here/imdb.

    stopassuming | Oct 24, 2011 | Reply

  38. What is the link to Karolyn’s blog

    Sally | Oct 24, 2011 | Reply

  39. he is not a bad boy. he is an adorable boy. love you shia =) Shia please take care and be careful with bad people that makes you angry I dont like that. omg I want to hug you. =)

    i wish i could go to vancouver and take care of you and hug you .
    =)

    mary26 | Oct 24, 2011 | Reply

  40. With his girl or no, hope he is doing well! No news? Maybe he is filming, would love some on-set shots.

    @mary26

    You are going to have to get in the hug line! LOL

    @stopassuming

    As a rule, I suspect EVERYTHING I read online. Was just wishing the boy a good weekend. pfft, don’t be a brat!

    peace, all.

    ann | Oct 24, 2011 | Reply

  41. no news about Shia is good news…lol..But I wish they would state that his head injuries were not serious. Then at least we’d know a Dr. checked him out.
    @ NoName…hope you have a great week ahead of you.
    Hey gang, by Wednesday we should see the usual Latte pics on the bike. Let’s hope he is wearing a helmut & is traveling with a body guard the size of Arnold Schwertzenegar.

    EmilyVP | Oct 24, 2011 | Reply

  42. @ann yes it is friend lol =) i want to hug him and take care of him. i wish i could go to vancouver.

    mary26 | Oct 24, 2011 | Reply

  43. http://justjared.buzznet.com/2011/10/25/jason-statham-replacing-shia-labeouf-in-transformers/

    Ash | Oct 25, 2011 | Reply

  44. Thank you Ash :)

    Star | Oct 25, 2011 | Reply

  45. WOAH how annoying!!! those three guys @ the end.. “specially the one saying “you want a hug” get off his nuts!

    Ellie | Oct 25, 2011 | Reply

  46. OMG Shia’s dad is a sex offender…
    Link:

    http://ohnotheydidnt.livejournal.com/63822614.html

    Amy | Oct 25, 2011 | Reply

  47. This is where Shia gets his troubles from. Yikes!
    As Transformers star Shia LaBeouf rises to Hollywood’s A-list, his father has notoriety of another sort — he’s a registered sex offender.

    Jeffrey Craig LaBeouf spent time behind bars between 1981 and 1983, after being convicted of attempted rape, Star magazine has exclusively learned.

    The conviction means that he is listed on the Megan’s Law website, which gives people access to sex offenders across America.

    “The Megan’s Law website is 100% accurate,” says Nick Pacilio, a spokesman for the Attorney General’s office. “If a person is on that website, they are a sex offender.”

    But someone may be trying to erase Jeffrey’s devious past. Star has learned that all official police documentation associated with the assault has inexplicably vanished. Yet the online Department of Justice confirms the crime, describing it as “assault with intent to commit rape.”

    In the same year as his rape offense, Jeffrey was also charged with kidnapping and assault with a deadly weapon, but the legal outcomes of these charges are unknown.

    Shia may know nothing of his father’s heinous crime, which was committed before he was even born.

    But Jeffrey was accused of sexual harassment by an actress on the set of Shia’s first major acting gig, Even Stevens.

    On another occasion, Jeffrey was accused of attacking a gay Disney executive who gave him a congratulatory hug.

    Shia even recounted the incident to a magazine a few years later, admitting that his dad practically threw the man through the wall.

    Sadly, Shia’s father, who worked as a mime and occasionally lived in a teepee in Montana, didn’t reserve his violent outbursts for strangers. The 25-year-old star alleged that his father verbally and physically abused him, claiming the Vietnam vet once held a gun to his head during a war flashback.

    Even worse, it seems that a penchant for trouble is something Jeffrey passed down to his famous son. The handsome actor has had numerous run-ins with the law, including a DUI arrest, a bar fight, a drunken street brawl and an assault arrest when he was just 19 after he tried to stab a neighbor.

    Shia’s rep did not return phone calls for comment.

    Read more at ONTD: http://ohnotheydidnt.livejournal.com/63822614.html#ixzz1boD1f4QZ

    OMG | Oct 25, 2011 | Reply

  48. I saw this unfortunate business this AM because another rag mag posted it at 730AM…Eastern time. I was hoping it would be taken down. It was posted by Radar OnLine…and they were awaiting to hear from Shia’s Publicist or PR people.
    I think it’s outrageous to post this crap because even if it is true:
    1. Shia may have never heard about it, as the article on Radar Online says. He wasn’t even born when this thing happened.
    2. It’s particularly low to be posted right after Shia has been beaten…on video no less. He hasn’t even had time to get off the cement pavement & they are trying to knock him down again. Unbelieveable.
    3. To make it worse, the last paragraph of the Radar Online article is questioning if his actions were passed down to Shia. What crap is this? WHAT AN OUTRAGE? No person is responsible for their parents behavior. They have no credit if the parent is a CEO of the planet? How did a parent contribute to his mother or father being the CEO of a company? They didn’t. Further every CEO does not have a child who also becomes a CEO. The same applies if the parent were a theif. Every child whose parents were jailed for being theives do not turn out to be thiefs.
    Every drunk that every lived does not produce a child who becomes a drunk. What crap!
    Yes there are exceptions. There can be tendencies, but no one can say who is going to follow in their parents exact footsteps. Further people can do wrong, but they can also stop doing wrong and do right. Bringing up something that happened years ago about someone’s parent is crap.
    His dad is elderly and he did serve in the US forces (I don’t know which one). How can anyone say what he went through & how it affected him?
    I honestly think someone who knows this family very well, is probably selling this info to these rag mags. What a shame.

    EmilyVP | Oct 25, 2011 | Reply

  49. Oh this makes me sick. And I feel a little guilty; it is the public’s need to know attitude that brings thinks like this about. We believe we have a right to know about what goes on in the lives of celebrities.

    Poor Shia. Even if he knew, not his fault. Poor, poor baby. What was the purpose of running this, what does it gain?

    Hopefully, he can find peace despite this crap. At the least, it may win him some sympathy.

    ann | Oct 25, 2011 | Reply

  50. I think it’s pathetic that he drags his family into this.
    his PR team shouldn’t talk shit about the man with the golden sperm.

    a.a.h. | Oct 25, 2011 | Reply

  51. seriously you’re blaming his pr team for this? you all know absolutely nothing about pr then.

    stopassuming | Oct 25, 2011 | Reply

  52. Well my parents are not the best people in the world, but I am not making the same mistakes. Hey Shia is already doing better than his parents by a long shot. I would love to hear his life story I bet he is an interesting person who had to overcome alot.

    :) | Oct 26, 2011 | Reply

  53. OMG JUST PLEASSE LEAVE SHIA ALONNNNEEEE!!!! PLEASEEEE SHEEESH!!!!

    ess217 | Oct 26, 2011 | Reply

  54. I agree with you @ ess217

    Mary26 | Oct 26, 2011 | Reply

  55. Love you shia =]

    Mary26 | Oct 26, 2011 | Reply

  56. is that mug shot of Shia’s dad from 1981?
    LOL

    aa | Oct 28, 2011 | Reply

Post a Comment